Citizens’ rights must not be forgotten at the 2026 UK-EU Summit

In July, as Andy Burnham became Prime Minister, we wrote to him with British in Europe, urging the Government to ensure that the UK’s reset with the European Union includes a renewed commitment to faithfully implementing and protecting citizens’ rights under the Withdrawal Agreement.

The reply from Hamish Falconer, the EU relations minister, assured us that citizens’ rights would remain at the heart of the Government’s work with the EU at all levels.

In recent weeks we have heard a lot about food rules and youth mobility. The promises made on citizens’ rights must not be forgotten in these negotiations.

In several key areas, the3million considers that the UK continues to breach the Withdrawal Agreement. The European Commission has repeatedly made clear at the twice-yearly EU-UK Specialised Committee on Citizens’ Rights that it shares our concerns.

On three of these issues we have had to take the UK Government to court – something we would far rather avoid, and which requires significant resources to fight for rights which are meant to be protected already.

We set out these concerns below - along with a new threat to EU citizens’ families from the Government’s ‘earned settlement’ reforms - and look forward to seeing progress on them in the agreement announced at the summit.

Our five asks for the summit

  1. Status removal: Give everyone a fair proportionality assessment and a right of appeal before their EU Settlement Scheme status is removed.
  2. People waiting for a decision: Accept a Certificate of Application as proof of rights for travel, driving licences and EHIC cards.
  3. Late applicants and vulnerable people: Stop charging people granted status after a late application for past NHS care, and fund help for vulnerable people to secure their status.
  4. Digital status: Properly define “adequately documented” for digital-only status, and give people more control over their proof of status.
  5. Families: Keep partners of EU Settlement Scheme status holders on the five-year route to settlement.

More on each ask below.

 

1. Uphold safeguards around losing Withdrawal Agreement status

People granted rights under the Withdrawal Agreement can lose them if they do not meet its conditions. But the Brexit negotiators included essential EU free movement procedural safeguards around loss of status for good reason.

The UK Government is now ignoring those safeguards whenever it claims it granted status by mistake. Rights are being allowed to expire silently, with no right of appeal and no proportionality assessment. The safeguards exist precisely so that the Home Office cannot compound its own errors with incorrect ‘granted in error’ findings. And there is a vast difference between removing status within days or weeks of a mistaken grant, and tearing people’s lives apart years later.

We tried throughout 2025 to resolve this through advocacy, and have now issued a judicial review.

Summit ask of the UK Government: Remove the need for this to go to trial – give everyone a fair proportionality assessment and a right of appeal before removing their EU Settlement Scheme status.

 

2. Respect people’s rights while waiting for Withdrawal Agreement status

The Withdrawal Agreement is clear: people who have applied for status must have access to all their Withdrawal Agreement rights while they wait for a decision, as evidenced by their Certificate of Application (CoA).

The UK Government fails to comply with this in several ways. The DVLA refuses to issue driving licences to people who are waiting, the NHS refuses to issue them EHIC cards, and the Government refuses to accept a CoA as evidence of the right to travel back to the UK.

After years of advocacy we have had to go to court, and are now awaiting a permission decision on our judicial review.

Summit ask of the UK Government: Remove the need for this to go to trial – accept a CoA for travel and when issuing driving licences and EHIC cards. This needs no legislation, only a change in guidance.

 

3. Treat late applicants fairly and protect vulnerable groups

We welcome the UK Government’s recognition that late applications must be accepted, even years after the deadline, where people have good reasons for missing the deadline. Before Brexit, the UK – unlike many other EU member states – never required EU citizens to register their presence. No one knew how many EU citizens lived here: our organisation took its name from the Government’s estimate back then of three million.

The Government wants to avoid a repeat of the Windrush scandal, and understands that many people only realise they need to deal with the Home Office years or decades after the deadline – prompted by a change of job, a trip abroad, or a need for hospital treatment. There are still between 1,500 and 2,000 grants of status to late applicants every month – a sign of how many people should have applied to the EU Settlement Scheme but did not know to, or could not.

But in one crucial respect, the Government’s policy makes no sense. Late applicants who are accepted as having had reasonable grounds for missing the deadline, and who go on to be granted EU Settlement Scheme status, remain permanently liable for any NHS charges incurred before they applied. In other words, the Government permanently punishes people it accepts had good reason to miss an administrative deadline.

Babies are charged for treatment because their parents did not apply before they were three months old. Elderly people are charged when an emergency hospital admission is what reveals they needed to apply. With NHS treatment charged at 150% of cost in these circumstances, bills can run to tens or hundreds of thousands of pounds. Only a small number of people are affected and the sums are a negligible fraction of the NHS budget – but for those people, they can mean financial ruin.

Once again, the Government ignored our advocacy and allowed the issue to go to court instead.

Late applicants are also increasingly left without help. In March 2026, the UK Government stopped all funding to help eligible vulnerable citizens secure their Withdrawal Agreement protection, reasoning that so few people still needed help that funding was no longer required. The monthly grant figures and our inbox tell a different story.

Our inbox – and those of the advice organisations we speak to – is full of desperate pleas from people in increasingly complex situations. The EU Settlement Scheme rules have become so complicated that late applicants now have virtually no chance of securing status without specialist legal advice.

With no funding and no legal aid, this situation is untenable. People contact us saying ‘please help, we’ve nowhere else to turn’, and we have to say ‘we’re not legally allowed to give immigration advice, and we cannot find organisations with capacity to help you’.

Summit ask of the UK Government: Remove the need for the NHS charging case to go to the Court of Appeal. A simple change to the NHS Charging Regulations through secondary legislation would mean that everyone granted EU Settlement Scheme status is treated as having been a Withdrawal Agreement beneficiary – and therefore entitled to free NHS healthcare – all along.

Summit ask of both the UK Government and the EU: Ensure funding remains available to help vulnerable people in increasingly complex situations secure their status. Vital specialist EU Settlement Scheme knowledge is being lost as organisations close their doors for lack of funding.

 

4. Fix digital status and travel problems

The Withdrawal Agreement requires that people be given a document evidencing their status and rights, and allows that document to be digital. The UK is the only party to have taken up the digital option – all EU member states give British citizens a physical card proving their Withdrawal Agreement rights.

During the Brexit negotiations it was not clear what a digital document would look like. What the Home Office built is not a document at all. Instead of a digital document held by the status holder and secured by a QR code, status holders must generate a share code and checkers must verify it – both online, both following a multi-step process.

This is not fit for purpose in time-pressured situations, for digitally excluded people, or wherever internet access is a problem. People have no control over their own proof of status.

This is most evident in international travel. The Home Office has built automated systems for carriers to check status, and issued guidance on what to do when those systems fail. Yet we keep hearing from people denied boarding because carriers did not follow that guidance. These people then cannot get compensation, because it is their word against the carrier’s that they were ‘adequately documented’.

Summit ask of the UK Government: In the short term, commit to secondary legislation that properly defines ‘adequately documented’ in this new era of digital-only travel rights, so that people can rely on their consumer protection rights when travelling home to the UK. In the medium term, commit to an honest discussion about forms of digital proof of status that give holders more control.

 

5. Keep EU Settlement Scheme families on the five-year route to settlement

Partners of people with EU Settlement Scheme status whose relationship began after 31 December 2020 are not eligible for the scheme. Instead, they must apply for a family visa under Appendix FM – with visa fees, Immigration Health Surcharges and minimum income requirements. Under the Earned Settlement changes announced on 2 November, most of them will now wait twice as long to settle. According to the Home Office, 39,000 people in total will face a wait of up to ten years – years more of uncertainty and cost.

The Government is keeping the shorter five-year route for those with a ‘uniquely strong attachment’ to the UK – but has decided that only family members of British citizens, and Commonwealth citizens on the UK Ancestry route, meet that test. Families of people with settled status are excluded, even though their lives are just as firmly rooted here. In 2018, the Government told the Home Affairs Committee that future partners of EU citizens with settled status would meet the same requirements as partners of British citizens: ‘This will mean equal treatment for EU and British citizens who marry foreign nationals.’ That promise is now being undermined. Some sponsors would like to become British, but their country of origin, such as the Netherlands, does not allow dual citizenship – so they cannot show a ‘British Connection’ either.

In February, the UK and EU reiterated their joint priority of protecting the rights of EU citizens in the UK ‘now and in the future’. We have written to the Minister for Migration and Citizenship asking to meet to discuss these concerns.

Summit ask of the UK Government: Keep partners of EU Settlement Scheme status holders on the five-year route to settlement, honouring the 2018 promise of equal treatment with British citizens.

 

get involved  Join our campaigns